Deleted
Deleted Member
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 14, 2018 6:37:42 GMT
In this age of hedonism and degeneracy, the fall of traditional values has been happening for a long while now. Do y'all think that traditional values will ever become mainstream again?
|
|
Clovis Merovingian
Prestige/VIP
Elder
Posts: 2,689
Likes: 1,757
Meta-Ethnicity: Anglo-American
Ethnicity: Deep Southerner
Country: My State and my Region are my country
Region: The Deep South
Location: South Carolina
Ancestry: Gaelic (patrilineal), English, Ulster Scots/Scots Irish, Scottish, German, Swiss German, Swedish, Manx, Finnish, Norman French/Quebecois (distantly), Dutch (distantly)
Taxonomy: Borreby/Alpine/ Nordid mix
Y-DNA: R-S660/R-DF109
mtDNA: T1a1
Politics: Conservative
Religion: Christian
Hero: Andrew Jackson, Thomas Jefferson, James K. Polk
Age: 30
Philosophy: I try to find out what is true as best I can.
|
Post by Clovis Merovingian on Mar 30, 2018 9:52:01 GMT
In this age of hedonism and degeneracy, the fall of traditional values has been happening for a long while now. Do y'all think that traditional values will ever become mainstream again? Man feudalism was great .
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 30, 2018 19:51:47 GMT
In this age of hedonism and degeneracy, the fall of traditional values has been happening for a long while now. Do y'all think that traditional values will ever become mainstream again? No its too late That profile pic is godly, God is a Serbian Southerner .
|
|
|
Post by joustos on Mar 30, 2018 20:48:14 GMT
"Traditional Western values" How cute.And which values would that be?I mean the values specifically identified as "western" and "traditional",and what this even mean? We must distinguish the values which are in effect in society (such as the Puritanical values) in various parts of Europe and in the U.S.A., and the ideal values which some men discussed and advocated, such as Plato's cardinal virtues: moderation; courage; justice {toward others: Render unto each his own [what is due to him]; don't make false accusations; don't bear false witness}; and wisdom (acquiring true knowledge; good counsel; etc.), and other virtues (such as Piety: respect for the gods and for men), and Cicero's precondition of the particular virtues: Love (love of spouse and children, and of men in general). I would add another virtue, which is typical of European Caucasoid people: The loving or the creating, and the acquiring, of Beauty. Here, too, it was Plato that spoke of the ascent of the mind through various kinds of beauty -- Sensory (or of the arts), ethical (as of the laws, which are for the sake of order, cosmicity, in society),mathematical or logical, and "ontological" [of Beauty in itself, as a Ding an Sich]. // I don't like a return to the values of any particular historical period; I like to see the promotion of the ideal values which the Western philosophers have already discussed.
|
|
mothman
Junior Member
Posts: 64
Likes: 39
Taxonomy: Homo Sapiens
Politics: Labels are meaningless.
Religion: Undecided.Leaning towards atheism.
Hero: George Carlin,Patton Oswalt,Capitain Price (from COD franchise),Jan Zizka.....(more will be added)
Age: 25
|
Post by mothman on Mar 30, 2018 21:10:29 GMT
"Traditional Western values" How cute.And which values would that be?I mean the values specifically identified as "western" and "traditional",and what this even mean? We must distinguish the values which are in effect in society (such as the Puritanical values) in various parts of Europe and in the U.S.A., and the ideal values which some men discussed and advocated, such as Plato's cardinal virtues: moderation; courage; justice {toward others: Render unto each his own [what is due to him]; don't make false accusations; don't bear false witness}; and wisdom (acquiring true knowledge; good counsel; etc.), and other virtues (such as Piety: respect for the gods and for men), and Cicero's precondition of the particular virtues: Love (love of spouse and children, and of men in general). I would add another virtue, which is typical of European Caucasoid people: The loving or the creating, and the acquiring, of Beauty. Here, too, it was Plato that spoke of the ascent of the mind through various kinds of beauty -- Sensory (or of the arts), ethical (as of the laws, which are for the sake of order, cosmicity, in society),mathematical or logical, and "ontological" [of Beauty in itself, as a Ding an Sich]. // I don't like a return to the values of any particular historical period; I like to see the promotion of the ideal values which the Western philosophers have already discussed. You mean western philosophers like Plato and Cicero?What makes them western?What makes puritans western?You are ignoring the fact that "the West" is so much heterogeneous that what ever set of values you point out at and declare it as mainstream,there vould be a large parts of "the West" that doesn't accept them and doesn;t Identify with them.To give an example,the culture in Amsterdam is not the same as Sicily,or Bavaria.So which one of them is more western? Same goes for "the East".It's not the same in Japan,Vietnam,and Korea,and let's say Belgrade and Moscow. Not to even mention the fact that sometimes you can find more similarity between some "eastern"city or a country with a "western" one than it has with some other "eastern" ones and vice versa. Also,most of the philosophers you've mentioned are well known and respected in both "east" and "west" which kinda makes them unoversal.Especially since most of them lived before the division between "the west" and the rest.
|
|
|
Post by joustos on Mar 31, 2018 15:10:50 GMT
We must distinguish the values which are in effect in society (such as the Puritanical values) in various parts of Europe and in the U.S.A., and the ideal values which some men discussed and advocated, such as Plato's cardinal virtues: moderation; courage; justice {toward others: Render unto each his own [what is due to him]; don't make false accusations; don't bear false witness}; and wisdom (acquiring true knowledge; good counsel; etc.), and other virtues (such as Piety: respect for the gods and for men), and Cicero's precondition of the particular virtues: Love (love of spouse and children, and of men in general). I would add another virtue, which is typical of European Caucasoid people: The loving or the creating, and the acquiring, of Beauty. Here, too, it was Plato that spoke of the ascent of the mind through various kinds of beauty -- Sensory (or of the arts), ethical (as of the laws, which are for the sake of order, cosmicity, in society),mathematical or logical, and "ontological" [of Beauty in itself, as a Ding an Sich]. // I don't like a return to the values of any particular historical period; I like to see the promotion of the ideal values which the Western philosophers have already discussed. You mean western philosophers like Plato and Cicero?What makes them western?What makes puritans western?You are ignoring the fact that "the West" is so much heterogeneous that what ever set of values you point out at and declare it as mainstream,there vould be a large parts of "the West" that doesn't accept them and doesn;t Identify with them.To give an example,the culture in Amsterdam is not the same as Sicily,or Bavaria.So which one of them is more western? Same goes for "the East".It's not the same in Japan,Vietnam,and Korea,and let's say Belgrade and Moscow. Not to even mention the fact that sometimes you can find more similarity between some "eastern"city or a country with a "western" one than it has with some other "eastern" ones and vice versa. Also,most of the philosophers you've mentioned are well known and respected in both "east" and "west" which kinda makes them unoversal.Especially since most of them lived before the division between "the west" and the rest. I used "western" simply in the geographical sense, and I assumed that the values or virtues in question are universal (rather than ethnically restricted). I have not tried to identify the "traditional" [western] values, some of which I like, and others I hate. In view of the philosophers I mentioned, the values which they deal with can be classified as "moral values". Here I agree with Plato that virtue cannot be taught, imparted. It cannot be imposed as a law, either. So, I have no idea as to how a moral reform in a society can be attained. Anyway, there are other values besides the moral ones which should be realized, but how? How? For instance, esthetes are born, not made. As they are the patrons of the arts [valuables, for me], the production of art-works depends equally on them and on persons who have artistic talents. Brain biology (as of a race of people) determines -- by chance, not by design --what a society's values shall be. (This topic is still open for thought and discussion.)
|
|
mothman
Junior Member
Posts: 64
Likes: 39
Taxonomy: Homo Sapiens
Politics: Labels are meaningless.
Religion: Undecided.Leaning towards atheism.
Hero: George Carlin,Patton Oswalt,Capitain Price (from COD franchise),Jan Zizka.....(more will be added)
Age: 25
|
Post by mothman on Mar 31, 2018 17:03:29 GMT
Again,even geographically it's not really correct.Because as I pointed out before in this thread,any value or a social norm that you can find in parts of the world known as "the West" also existed to an extent in so called east.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 31, 2018 17:17:53 GMT
It's not just limited to western european values, but, overall, the culture and traditions, which once ensured peace and harmony. Unfortunately, even in India, which boasts of so called culture, I can see the decline in morality of individual, and it is all because of the individuality,materialistic value which has taken precedence.
So, as @polaris has pointed out, until and unless these things will not go, there's no HOPE.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 1, 2018 18:54:13 GMT
In this age of hedonism and degeneracy, the fall of traditional values has been happening for a long while now. Do y'all think that traditional values will ever become mainstream again? No. And we don't want it be bringing back. Praise for Lord liberal things goes pretty funny, and tomorrow every traditionalist will gone. Liberal traditions will rule the Earth!
|
|
ajay0
Full Member
Posts: 162
Likes: 79
|
Post by ajay0 on Apr 2, 2018 16:06:43 GMT
I am in favour of traditional western values which created a Newton or Einstein, Napoleon or Kemal Ataturk.
Western values which created a Mussolini, Hitler , Wilhelm II and the Dark Ages are probably better to be discarded as trash.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 3, 2018 19:22:51 GMT
I am in favour of traditional western values which created a Newton or Einstein, Napoleon or Kemal Ataturk. Western values which created a Mussolini, Hitler , Wilhelm II and the Dark Ages are probably better to be discarded as trash. Good reasoning, but they say that the traditions which created Newtons, also created Hitlers. The most common reason of that - rational attitude to everything. As the matter of fact, Nazi's program was very clever and rational, this didn't prevented it from the camps. (By the way, they say that Britain was the first who used it in North Africa. I'm not sure I've heard it from the lecturer of mine.) So, being rational means in potential - to be Nazi. I think that such thought costs nothing but dumb mark. Anyway, after wwii politics, economic and the though itself went more polite and not so strict as before. At the present it seems to be consciousness problem that parasites the traditional ones which lived by their past only. We can see some example in our time. I'd say that the topic is still under discussions. The question concerns the problem of mind, the more core problems. I'm glad that there are such philosophers as W. Quine, D. Davidson and H. Putman who made the problem more clear to us, by solving the consciousness problem.
|
|
Sonny
Full Member
Posts: 248
Likes: 84
Ancestry: European
Religion: Christian
|
Post by Sonny on Apr 12, 2018 22:28:17 GMT
In it's current state, the West will not survive if they don't.
As a society we cannot survive without morals or religion. Fundamentally, we as a species have evolved to be religious. To believe in a Truth. But if there is no belief anymore, if everything is subjective, then what do you do? It's chaos, everything is scattered. There are just an infinite number of opinions, but no Truth. And that is the end of civilization as we know it.
|
|